AMD Opteron 2000 vs Intel Xeon 5100 review

  • Price When Reviewed: 3710 . 3825

Best prices today

Retailer Price Delivery  

Price comparison from over 24,000 stores worldwide

The ‘chip wars’ between AMD and Intel have being going in the former’s favour for the last few years – at least as far as workstations are concerned. In the past month though, Intel has launched a major offensive with the recent release of its Xeon 5100 range – previously codenamed ‘Woodcrest’ and based on the same chip technology behind the company’s Core Duo processors – and AMD has returned fire with its Opteron 2000 range.

So which of these two technologies is the best for your next workstation? To help us find out, Armari kindly built us two near-identical systems based around two equivalent versions of each chip. Unusually these are nearly equal in speed – two dual-core 2.66GHz Xeon 5150s against two dual-core 2.6GHz Opteron 2218s – as well as price, when you factor in the overall cost including the motherboard and the relevant types of RAM.

To give the processors the chance to strut their stuff, each workstation included 8GB of RAM, a top-rated ATI (soon to be AMD) Fire GL V7300 graphics card, two 10,000rpm hard drives and a copy of Windows XP 64-bit. This pushes the overall price towards the £4,000 mark, but it would easily be possible to design a more affordable system around either chip.

Of the new chips, Intel’s Xeon’s 5100 line is the greatest leap from the previous generation. The chips have two processor cores and 2MB of Level 2 cache, and the front-side bus speed has been raised to 1.3GHz. They add support for FB-DIMM DDR2 memory, which is apparently more reliable than previous types, and use a lot less power than older Xeons (keeping your power bills down and helping save the planet). It’s the change to the Core architecture that’s made the most difference, boosting overall performance dramatically.

These are also the chips used by Apple’s first Intel-based workstation, the Mac Pro.

 border=0 />Our two 5150’s were fixed to a Supermicro X7DAE motherboard, which uses Intel’s 5000X ‘Greencreek’ chipset. Unfortunately, the cooling required for this and the RAM meant that it had to be housed in an enormous, noisy Supermicro SC743T-645 chassis (right) – though Armari says that it will have a quieter configuration using a traditional-sized case by the time you read this.
AMD’s Opteron 2200 range is less of an upgrade than the Xeon 5100s. It uses a new connection known as Socket F but its main advantage for creatives is support for faster DDR2 memory. Our test system used a pre-production Asus KFN32-D motherboard with an nVidia MCP55Pro chipset, and sat inside Armari’s traditional Supermicro SC733T-645 chassis (below) – and was much smaller and quieter than the Xeon set-up.
<div class=floatedimage><img src=Share

Note: We may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site, at no extra cost to you. This doesn't affect our editorial independence. Learn more.

Read Next...